Sensible Magic 2 Overview: They Put the Lime within the Coconut Once more

Followers adore the scene within the unique Sensible Magic the place the Owens household enjoys some midnight margaritas to the sounds of Harry Nilsson’s “Coconut.” Whereas the track is an iffy selection for that individual scene — Nilsson was positively not singing about margaritas  — it’s an ideal match for Sensible Magic as an entire, which is each a heartwarming drama concerning the unbreakable bond between sisters and likewise a surprisingly darkish comedy about witches, curses, murders, household trauma, and our bodies buried in shallow graves. It’s all clashing tones and genres. It’s all tart and candy blended collectively.

Elements of Sensible Magic 2 work, and others don’t. But when nothing else, this long-awaited sequel positively recreates that lime within the coconut combine, with fan service giving solution to romance adopted by mystical battle scenes that recommend the Owens sisters is perhaps distant cousins of Physician Unusual. It’s a wierd and unpredictable mixture — which, in its personal quirky means, makes it trustworthy to the primary movie. 

A true late ’90s oddity, Sensible Magic owes its longevity to its singular qualities. There are only a few motion pictures, then or now, that discover sister relationships with such earnestness. There are additionally only a few motion pictures like this interval, ones with huge stars and heat lighting and consuming montages and the occasional poisoning and/or bludgeoning.

READ MORE: The Finest Films of 2026 So Far

It’s additionally obtained Sandra Bullock and Nicole Kidman as witchy sisters Sally and Gilly Owens, who stand by one another’s facet by means of lifeless husbands and abusive boyfriends and that aforementioned household curse that ensures any man they love will die. With Bullock and Kidman again collectively for the primary time in many years, Sensible Magic 2 depends closely on their simple onscreen rapport, which retains this sequel afloat by means of some very questionable plotting.

Some 30 years after the occasions of the primary movie, Sally and Gilly are nonetheless collectively and nonetheless cursed. Sally’s two daughters Kylie (Joey King) and Antonia (Maisie Williams) are actually grown up, with no clue they’re descended from an extended line of highly effective witches. (Sally was so devastated by the lack of her husband that she renounced her items and swore the remainder of the household to secrecy.) That pact held till Kyle fell for a candy man named Gideon (Cobra Kai’s Xolo Maridueña) and, effectively, the lime goes again within the coconut once more.

Certainly one of Sensible Magic’s pleasures — and a giant motive why it’s so rewatchable and have become such a primary cable basic — are its cozy vibes. The Owens’ Victorian home, the sisterhood, the late evening cocktails poured across the island in that fabulous kitchen. It’s an outsized sweater of a film; it doesn’t match nice, and it’s a little bit of a multitude, but it surely’s cozy as hell.

Sensible Magic 2 reconjures that very interesting world and its residents, and the early scenes properly seize that very same relaxed vitality. Dianne Wiest and Stockard Channing each return as Sally and Gilly’s aunts Jet and Franny, and there are pretty little moments between the assorted generations of Owenses as they bake, booze, change items, and have a look at books.

Regrettably, a narrative should inevitably begin. A number of Owens household crises converage, and ship the sisters off to England. There, they enlist the help of a good-looking professor of magical historical past named Ian Wright (“Mr. Proper,” tee hee), who Sally and Gilly uncover in his London house bare and within the throes of a mysterious magical spell. As soon as saved by the sisters, Ian (Lee Tempo) is so distracted by Sally’s luminous magnificence that he can’t be bothered to determine who tried to kill him. (Severely: In the event you had been almost murdered by a lethal hex, wouldn’t you at the very least be just a little curious who did it and why?)

The England sequences separate a variety of the forged from each other; in basic legacyquel trend, there are extra characters than the screentime can comfortably permit, and so just a few get pushed to the margins. Additionally in basic legacyquel trend, Sensible Magic 2 nods at handing off this sequence to the subsequent era of Owens sisters, then focuses most of its vitality on the A-list expertise whose faces are on the movie’s posters and whose names are above the title. Bullock and Kidman trudge by means of the English countryside till they arrive at an incongrously effects-heavy conclusion that nearly turns their characters into unofficial superheroes.

Susanne Bier, changing Griffin Dunne as franchise director, finds much more success in much less bombastic moments, those the place we get to understand the real connection between Bullock, Kidman, Wiest, and Channing. Does the entire movie maintain collectively? Not fairly, but when we’re being trustworthy Sensible Magic didn’t actually maintain collectively both. One thing about its messiness — and the way in which that messiness displays one thing genuine about life for these of us with out magical powers — makes it interesting. Sensible Magic 2 is perhaps a slight step down from the unique, however with time (and sufficient midnight margaritas) I may see it changing into one other home-video hit.

RATING: 5/10