Annie Dillard is rightly celebrated as a pioneer in creative nonfiction after her demise on Sep. 15, 2026, at age 81. However the dazzling, disorienting really feel of Dillard’s work is perhaps greatest understood as the usually ignored affect of poetry on her prose.
Dillard revealed her first full-length work of artistic nonfiction, “Pilgrim at Tinker Creek,” when she was solely 28. Profitable her the 1975 Pulitzer Prize, this early e book set the tone for her later work in artistic nonfiction: the essay assortment “Teaching a Stone to Talk,” and full-length works “Holy the Firm” and “For the Time Being.” All of them attend intently to the pure world, with a theologian’s eye and a poet’s idiom.
Dillard’s artistic nonfiction about nature owes a debt to the lyrical prose of transcendentalists like Henry David Thoreau, whom Dillard cited as a significant affect in her work. She was additionally overt in regards to the central position that fiction performed in her pondering in her e book of literary criticism, “Living by Fiction.”
However Dillard’s nonfiction, although undeniably prose, can have “the shape and intensity of a poem,” as her New York Occasions obituary places it.
As a writer and writing professor, I believe usually about how blurred the boundary between poetry and prose actually is. Annie Dillard’s work embodies this permeability.
Prose and poetry, together
Not all writing is similar. Prose usually options steady sentences organized in paragraphs. Poetry tends to be differentiated from prose by a deliberate group of language that’s not decided by the web page itself.
Prose poetry, the lyric essay and different hybrid types of literature play on the intersection of genre, which normally defines these separate classes of writing. Creative nonfiction likewise goals to precisely convey actuality whereas emphasizing literary model. The literary features of creative nonfiction are sometimes drawn from fiction, with gadgets corresponding to dialogue, scene and flashback.
However one of many distinctions of Annie Dillard’s nonfiction is how a lot her prose owes to poetry.
Sophie Park/The Washington Post via Getty Images
Poetry will be defined in many ways, but it surely tends to be characterised by honed, heightened language. Poems are sometimes famous for his or her memorable photographs, wealthy sounds and foregrounding of emotion. Dillard’s nonfiction is shot via with photographs that arrest readers with their magnificence or confront readers with their terror – as in her Harper’s essay “The Death of a Moth,” the place the insect is drawn to a candle flame, turns into caught within the wax and is remodeled right into a burning wick. In Dillard’s phrases:
“She burned for 2 hours with out altering, with out swaying or kneeling – solely glowing inside, like a constructing hearth glimpsed via silhouetted partitions, like a hole saint, like a flame-faced virgin gone to God, whereas I learn by her mild, kindled, whereas Rimbaud in Paris burnt out his mind in a thousand poems, whereas night time pooled wetly at my ft.”
It’s no accident that Dillard describes herself as studying the work of French poet Arthur Rimbaud by the sunshine of the moth. She beforehand wrote that she loved how language sounds in French symbolist poetry, and Rimbaud was identified to combine prose with his poetry in a method Dillard herself does.
Writing prose as a poet
In “The Writing Life,” Dillard describes the method of writing “a favourite, tough e book” – seemingly “Holy the Agency” – as akin to writing poetry. She notes that the writing was “so intense and accented, and the world it described was so charged with that means,” that the concept of going additional exhausted her.
To assist her write, she learn Conrad Aiken’s poetry aloud, describing it as “pure sound unencumbered by sense.” She would learn a poetry anthology’s index of first traces as a result of “the parallels sounded robust and suggestive.”
She additionally describes repeating a single line of Wallace Stevens’ poetry “for hours, like a music” whereas writing.
Dillard purposefully channeled poetry’s sonic density in her writing course of; it comes as no shock that the heightened register of those poems made its method into her prose.
Impressed by ineffable nature
Dillard’s virtuosic, visionary model isn’t for everybody. Author Eudora Welty praised Dillard in her review of “Tinker Creek,” however Welty additionally admitted “not (figuring out) what she’s speaking about” at instances and that her writing “leaves one thing to be desired.” That one thing was what Welty referred to as “straight narrative,” the readability of “level, path, and form” extra usually demanded of prose than poetry.
Mandel Ngan/AFP via Getty Images
The solitude of the narrator in Dillard’s nonfiction and her obvious disengagement with society additionally was a supply of criticism. As critic William Deresiewicz put it, “There may be no economy and no society” in “Tinker Creek.” “We don’t understand how Dillard lives, or how she makes a dwelling, or a lot of something about her circumstances.” Her mixture of cultural disengagement and theological concern smacked to Deresiewicz of “hypocrisy and religious snobbery.”
Within the contained world of lyric poetry, particularly nature poetry, this airtight perspective could be much less of a fault. Her mystical encounters with the divine via the pure world are harking back to poets like Gerard Manley Hopkins, Wendell Berry and Mary Oliver. The slim lens of her consideration will be seen as a poetic characteristic performed out at size over her nonfiction essays and books.
Like an expressionist painting, poetry attracts consideration to how one thing is being depicted, not simply what’s being portrayed. Prose can do that, too – artistic nonfiction, particularly, and Annie Dillard’s writing most of all.